This is the second installment from our guest blogger Thomas Keenan.
If you remember, Mr. Keenan found Pine History Blog while researching family history and he and I have emailed many, many times since.
He is currently writing a family history book and I asked him to write about finding his family in Pine Township.
To find Rebecca’s parents, I had to start out with what I knew.
Fortunately, I had well recorded histories of the Ward family that gave me plenty of information on Rebecca’s husband, Timothy Ward. Timothy’s father (also named Timothy) was a Revolutionary War veteran originally from New Jersey, but who had moved to western Pennsylvania by the early years of the nineteenth century.
By the War of 1812, the Wards had settled in Butler County, Pennsylvania, north of Pittsburgh. Timothy (the son) served during the war, enlisting as a musician with the 138th Pennsylvania Militia as part of the call to arms that followed after the British raid on Buffalo, New York in late 1813.
Timothy, who was listed in muster rolls as both a fifer and a drummer, marched to Erie, Pennsylvania with the regiment to defend against a suspected British attack that never came, and he would remain there through the winter months of 1814.
Given this information, I suspected that Rebecca’s family may have been from western Pennsylvania, but I couldn’t be sure.
According to the family histories I had, Timothy married Rebecca in 1818, but I did not have a location for the marriage. The Wards would move west during the 1820s, living for a time near Cincinnati (in Brown County) where they were located on the 1830 Census, before finally settling in southeastern Indiana by 1840.
I had searched for a marriage record to no avail, which is not surprising given that Pennsylvania did not mandate marriage licenses until the end of the nineteenth century.
In the absence of a marriage record which might name Rebecca’s parents, my thoughts turned to probate records. Assuming that Rebecca’s parents were in fact George and Sarah Wallace, perhaps there was a will establishing parentage.
Once again, however, the problem was location. Though I initially searched for the probate records of a George Wallace in Butler County, I could not locate any will that matched.
I had given up any hope of finding a will when I began drafting the portion of my book on Timothy and Rebecca Ward.
But when I came to actually writing my history on the couple, I found a gap in my research between the given year for their marriage in 1818 and the family’s move west to Ohio. I decided to take a closer look at the 1820 Census. I soon found an entry for a Timothy Ward in Pine Township, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, just to the north of Butler County.
As any family historian can attest, the Censuses prior to 1850 can be exceedingly frustrating to deal with as they do not name every individual in a household.
Instead, these Censuses only list heads of households, with the remaining members of the family allocated to numbers in pre-defined age ranges. Thus, for this Timothy Ward, the Census listed one male under the age of ten, one male between the ages of sixteen and twenty-six, and one female between the ages of sixteen and twenty-six.
Despite the utter impersonality of this method of record-keeping, the numbers actually matched up with my family histories. Based on the years of birth I had, Timothy would have been about twenty-seven in 1820; Rebecca, twenty-three; and their first child, a son named Eber, about one year old.
But what I found one household directly above Timothy was even more intriguing – a George Wallace. And two households above that, another George Wallace! This had to be more than coincidence.